×
×
homepage logo

Through The Lens “The Stain of Crime”

By Staff | Aug 15, 2025

A few weeks ago, I published a column titled “Spider Web of Justice.” In the story I spoke of the imbalance of justice, when influenced by an accused person’s position in power, or the community. Even when justice is served with conviction, the question goes beyond the guilt or innocence, when it comes to the penalty phase of the legal system.

The person charged with a crime is presumed innocent until proven guilty. That guilt is decided by a selected group of persons known as the jury. They weigh the evidence and in discussion outside the courtroom, are charged with deciding if a guilty or not guilty verdict should be rendered. They do this by hearing testimony, and real evidence presented by the court.

If in a case where hard physical evidence is presented, pictures, video, eye witness, or physical forensic evidence, the jury will likely decide that the prosecution has proven the defendant’s guilt beyond a reasonable doubt. This is the highest standard of proof in the U.S. legal system. It means the evidence presented must be so compelling and convincing that there’s no reasonable doubt about the defendant’s guilt. No question in anyone’s minds of the outcome.

But what if a jury is not given the chance to review the evidence. Both parties involved are the first to review the hard evidence, victim statements and any relevant evidence that will be placed before the court.

Prosecutors want an open and shut case. Clear and indisputable evidence of the crime. Prosecutors must have a clear understanding of every piece of evidence. Each piece must be clear and defined before it is given to the jury. But what if the evidence is not solid or clear? What if the only evidence is a video tape. You would think that with visual evidence of the crime, a prosecutor would have a case that the jury would find the defendant guilty beyond a reasonable doubt, after all each jury could see the crime with their own eyes.

In that case no prosecutor worth his salt would be part of a pre-trial plea agreement. Justice demands criminals be prosecuted to prevent the person committing another crime in the future. But if in deliberation, just one person believes reasonable doubt exists, the person could be found not guilty. Did the prosecution fail? Was the evidence not convincing? Or maybe the person charged is innocent? Going before a jury is never a sure thing without clear and indisputable evidence. In that case after careful review, the prosecution may decide to be sure to get a conviction, a plea deal may better serve public justice and get a sure imprisonment.

We ask the legal system to investigate and prosecute cases. In the recent case of Joseph Ward, the system did its job. He will spend time in jail and for the rest of his foreseeable life, he will be scrutinized at every moment. A prison has cold solid gray walls. The prison Mr. Ward will be in after his future release, may not be solid walled, but his life will be just as restrained by society. The Amish have a word for it, “Shunning.”

Is he guilty of the crime he was accused of, the judge said, “yes.” He may not have directly admitted guilt, but he understands the public says he committed a crime and must pay for his actions.

Out front of the court house, a couple dozen citizens expressed their displeasure at the court’s judgment and time to be spent in jail. People called out for the court to do its job, pound of flesh for pound of flesh, and eye for an eye. A few voices were heard shouting, “this should have been done long before.” That point could be raised by the defense. How long has this been going on? Did anyone question the curious activities in the close community? Did anyone, anyone step up and say, “something is not right.” Neighbors, school officials, law enforcement, social services. The community may have been able to prevent this terrible crime from happening if anyone would have seen something and said something.

I’ll bet some of those naysayers that have spent time trashing the prosecution, defense lawyer, judges and even local attorneys may have had some idea of a possible problem. Where was their scrutiny then?

The prosecution of child sex crimes is kind of like… Let me give you an example using your toilet. We each flush our toilets, and are happy when waste disappears. Once you have sent the unpleasantness on its way down the sewer system, someone must deal with it for the good of society. At the sewage plant south of town, the material will be processed, and made to be safe to re-enter the environment. You don’t think about the person whose job it is, to deal with human waste on a daily basis. The next time you stand next to the person in the grocery line who spent the day working with the waste, you may hold your nose. Do you give consideration to the important job he performs and how it makes your life better? Isn’t that in some ways what judges and prosecutors do for society? They deal with the unpleasant crimes and people flushed by society that you or I don’t want to deal with.

In all this turmoil we must not forget the victims of this horrendous crime, the children. If they had to take the stand and relive those events, would it have made it better for them? Don’t forget the defense attorney would question them about the happenings. The truth is, in cases such as this no one wins. Anyone near the case will be stained with the terribleness of the crimes.

Blaming the legal system because the pound of flesh is not big enough serves no purpose other than wanting them to share in the guilt of the crime. If they are to be blamed, what of those people who whispered, “Something is not right in that house.” Maybe if you look in the mirror, you will see someone who could have prevented the injury to these children, as we look back Through the Lens.